Peanut Butter Ice Cream

Experience the creamy delight of our handmade peanut butter goat milk ice cream, crafted with care at It's What You Keep. Made in small batches so it's always fresh, this pint-only treat is perfect for the peanut butter lover in your family. Ideal for hot summer days, our farm-fresh ice cream offers a delightful, satisfying escape. Treat yourself to a uniquely refreshing experience from our working dairy goat farm with an on-site creamery, bakery, and store. Enjoy the authentic taste of meticulous craftsmanship and farm-fresh ingredients.